[SmG Phoenix]

The bigger question is would you rather take part in the Battle of Hogwarts or Order 66. I feel like your chances of surviving the Battle of Hogwarts is much higher than Order 66. Only 56 out of 1000 students survive in the Hogwarts battle. But so few Jedi survive Order 66. But even those survivors got eliminated later on by the Galactic Empire.
So really you chances of being a Jedi is very very low. But as a Hogwarts student you have a much better chance of surviving.

I'm with you on this. There are too many factors to answer this question effectively. DeathBattle had a clearer cut idea of a 1v1. But this is far more open ended.

[Skywrath]

Jedi hands down. And thumbs up.

[SmG Battlefire]

Or we could just say if you were to join hogwarts, it would be after the huge battle
Or if you wanted to become a Jedi... welp, after that crap is resolved

Honestly, i'd rather be jedi, seems more up my alley

We have to choose from when the movies started or it wouldn't be a difficult choice. People would just creat loop holes for their own support.

Story rules:

If you choose Hogwarts. You started 1991, same time as Harry entered Hogwarts on his first year. Meaning you will face the Battle of Hogwarts in 1997 on your 7th year of Hogwarts. If you survive you finish you last year at Hogwarts which is the 8th year. You graduate and become a Aurar as a career in the Wizardry world. If you don't know Aurar are elite secret agents who fight and investigate crimes and enforce the law.

If you choose Judi you will start of at the same time Obi wan entered the Jedi as a Padawan. You also start of as a Padawan. In 30 years you will face Order 66. If you survive, you stay hidden till the Rebels find you. You join them against the Empire. After the war you are a Judi master and would help Luke rebuild the order.

Remember, you can still get killed during the Battle of Hogwarts or Order 66.
Hogwarts survival: 80%
Jedi survival: 30%

Edit: I said Jedi survival 10%. Thought that was too low. So 30% was more fit. Even though 99.9% of the Jedi got killed.

[SmG Phoenix]

^If you MUST be put into a timeframe and undergo training as you've set, then yeah, you are perfectly right. Unfortunately, must people have no foresight in this and simply looked at what's blatantly obvious and ticked what they locked.
Stinger asked for reason and most people aren't saying it. >:( Getting mildly salty because of that.

[SmG Stinger]

Yep, everyone must have a reason due to their decision

I still choose Jedi, as I am able to train for 30 years before order 66, meaning I can become a beast

P.S - I've PM'd all those who didnt give a reason, and have asked them to

[SmG Battlefire]

Yep, everyone must have a reason due to their decision

I still choose Jedi, as I am able to train for 30 years before order 66, meaning I can become a beast

P.S - I've PM'd all those who didnt give a reason, and have asked them to

Most of the Jedi trained longer than that and still got killed during Order 66.

It is a good idea to have time frames. So no one makes loop holes to get their way.

[SmG Phoenix]

Yep, everyone must have a reason due to their decision

I still choose Jedi, as I am able to train for 30 years before order 66, meaning I can become a beast

P.S - I've PM'd all those who didnt give a reason, and have asked them to

Didn't need to PM, but sure. Not a serious topic.

[SmG Blade]

Well Jedi is AWESOME... as i am 3lazy to move my ass, Force will help and Stinger is ri8... 30 years till Order 66...

[SmG Battlefire]

[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OJH2VSfQvYM[/youtube]

[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCuUIkEtJjo[/youtube]

The 501st Clone Legion would kick you Jedi asses. The most battle harden Clones in the Clone Army. You Jedi's need some god damn freedom. Order 66 brought you that freedom.

[Donald J Trump]

WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT.

Who said what time and place of jedi or hogwarts we come into, these timelines have existed for centuries.