[SmG Phoenix]

The bigger question is would you rather take part in the Battle of Hogwarts or Order 66. I feel like your chances of surviving the Battle of Hogwarts is much higher than Order 66. Only 56 out of 1000 students survive in the Hogwarts battle. But so few Jedi survive Order 66. But even those survivors got eliminated later on by the Galactic Empire.
So really you chances of being a Jedi is very very low. But as a Hogwarts student you have a much better chance of surviving.

I'm with you on this. There are too many factors to answer this question effectively. DeathBattle had a clearer cut idea of a 1v1. But this is far more open ended.