I read all these analyzations on forums and blogs especially made for these, where the actual data is put in by experts not just general opinions.
I just see this topic as a field where nebula puts his "expert" OPINIONS in.
Oh, and it seems someone has mentioned bout why AC doesn't win goty, its primarily cuz of the no of flaws it possesses as compared to some of the less popular games in its category(as I have read so).
And @ noobula