[SmG Phoenix]

WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT.

Who said what time and place of jedi or hogwarts we come into, these timelines have existed for centuries.

Explain. The 2 timelines have existed separately and probably differ by millenia. Otherwise picking Jedi into modern times would be OP.

[SmG Battlefire]

WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT.

Who said what time and place of jedi or hogwarts we come into, these timelines have existed for centuries.

Again it would make sense to have the timelines from when the movies started and ended. If I said I was going to be a Jedi after the defeat of the Galactic Empire that would be dumb due to the fact there isn't any challenge you would be in. All known sith are killed and you are the very few with the force. You would be OP is fuck.

For Hogwarts it goes the same. No real challenge because nothing really happened after the Battle of Hogwarts.

So if you chose Jedi you start as a Padawan. Same time Naboo gets Invaded by the Trade Federation.

If Hogwarts than you start your first year. Same time as Harry enters Hogwarts his first time.

[Donald J Trump]

WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT.

Who said what time and place of jedi or hogwarts we come into, these timelines have existed for centuries.

Again it would make sense to have the timelines from when the movies started and ended. If I said I was going to be a Jedi after the defeat of the Galactic Empire that would be dumb due to the fact there isn't any challenge you would be in. All known sith are killed and you are the very few with the force. You would be OP is fuck.

For Hogwarts it goes the same. No real challenge because nothing really happened after the Battle of Hogwarts.

So if you chose Jedi you start as a Padawan. Same time Naboo gets Invaded by the Trade Federation.

If Hogwarts than you start your first year. Same time as Harry enters Hogwarts his first time.

Thats just dumb and very limiting.

[SmG Phoenix]

No....?
It's more logical.

[SmG Battlefire]

WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT.

Who said what time and place of jedi or hogwarts we come into, these timelines have existed for centuries.

Again it would make sense to have the timelines from when the movies started and ended. If I said I was going to be a Jedi after the defeat of the Galactic Empire that would be dumb due to the fact there isn't any challenge you would be in. All known sith are killed and you are the very few with the force. You would be OP is ****.

For Hogwarts it goes the same. No real challenge because nothing really happened after the Battle of Hogwarts.

So if you chose Jedi you start as a Padawan. Same time Naboo gets Invaded by the Trade Federation.

If Hogwarts than you start your first year. Same time as Harry enters Hogwarts his first time.

Thats just dumb and very limiting.

How is that dumb? What you want to create infinite loop holes due to the fact you can choose the past or modern time? Adding these time frames actually makes people think when choosing Hogwarts or Jedi. It gives a consequence for each one.

Heck if there was no timeline. I could come up with something bullshit like I found a portal that took me to another dimension. Now here I am at the modern time ruling everyone with my Jedi power.

[SmG Phoenix]

Jedi is definitely the most OP without context.

[Skywrath]

Jedi is definitely the most OP without context.

That. Not to mention the fact Jedi wield the Force (which I would assume would be a cosmic power), which poor Harry has nothing on. Likewise a pokemon trainer would have nothing on both of them.

[SmG Battlefire]

Jedi is definitely the most OP without context.

That. Not to mention the fact Jedi wield the Force (which I would assume would be a cosmic power), which poor Harry has nothing on. Likewise a pokemon trainer would have nothing on both of them.

Actually the things you can do with the Force can be done with Magic. Like move objects or shoot out lightning. Some you don't even need a wand. But with Magic you have to actually concentrate and call out the name of the spell while as using the force takes full concentration.

And remember using the force isn't a easy thing. Most Jedi can't lift a huge object while so very few Jedi Masters can.

[SmG Stinger]

I've always liked lightsabers.. so Jedi all the way :D

[SmG Phoenix]

Jedi is definitely the most OP without context.

That. Not to mention the fact Jedi wield the Force (which I would assume would be a cosmic power), which poor Harry has nothing on. Likewise a pokemon trainer would have nothing on both of them.

In the context of Luke vs Harry, Harry's fucked. But if you were put into respect time frames, then no, Harry's world gives a far better chance of survival.